You are here:

What is indemnity insurance?

When buying or selling a property you might be advised to take out this insurance but what does does it actually cover and is it worth the cost?

Buying a property is likely to be the biggest investment you’ll ever make. To help ease some of the anxiety, insurance companies offer something called property indemnity insurance (sometimes referred to as building indemnity insurance). These policies protect against a range of legal risks and are often recommended by a conveyancing solicitor.

But it’s important to understand the limits. This type of insurance won’t pay for building repairs or replacements. Nor will it cover personal injury claims due to poor workmanship or for any fines incurred from a local authority order, explain solicitors Pettyson & Prestwich.

A bungalow with a Sold sign outside it and a car on the drive

Why do solicitors recommend it? 

Property sales often uncover missing paperwork or unapproved home improvements. According to a survey by Direct Line Insurance, nine out of ten estate agents have been asked to sell properties with unlawful renovations.

Removal of load bearing walls, new windows overlooking neighbours’ properties and loft conversions are among the most common projects done without the necessary planning permission or building regulations approvals.

For buyers, this can be a problem because in the worst-case scenario, councils can order the work to be reversed – though this is rare.

When a buyer’s solicitor flags up an issue, there are usually three ways forward. The seller can be asked to put things right, for example by applying for retrospective planning permission, Alternatively, the buyer can pull out of the sale. And a third option is to take out indemnity insurance to protect against legal costs arising from the issue. 

Resolving the underlying issue is the ideal solution – but if it’s too costly, time-consuming or simply impossible, indemnity insurance is often recommended by conveyancing solicitors. 

According to Pettyson & Prestwich: “Many buyers seek out indemnity insurance in order to allow the purchase to proceed and giving themselves peace of mind against the worst-case scenario coming to pass.”

What does indemnity insurance cover?

Indemnity insurance covers the policyholder for one, specific issue. As Pettyson and Prestwich explain: “Should there be a future claim against you by a third party in relation to the issue, you’ll be covered and won’t face any legal costs. It will also cover any loss of value (with the property) directly related to the problem you have taken cover out for.”

Sometimes, multiple policies are taken out to cover a range of risks. “We have sold properties with four or five indemnity insurance policies,” says Paul Preen, director of Lang, Town and Country estate agents, adding: “Some of them are just farcical.”

For example, Preen  recently sold a house with a loft conversion built 50 years ago, before building regulations even applied (introduced in 1984). Unsurprisingly, there was no building regulations certificate. “The lender was happy, but the solicitor still recommended an indemnity policy,” says Preen. This was despite the council’s 12-year enforcement period having long expired.

In another case, a seller couldn’t produce a gas installation certificate for a new boiler. The buyer was recommended to get the heating system checked by a qualified engineer for safety and take out an £80 indemnity policy to cover potential legal costs. In this scenario, Preen is clear on what really matter. “The gas safety check gives more real peace of mind.”

That’s why buyers should always arrange proper building surveys and safety checks for boilers, electrics and plumbing. Don’t just rely on indemnity insurance – it won’t make a property safe or cover repairs or replacement if something is faulty. “It might be simpler to fix the problem rather than paper over the cracks with an insurance policy,” note Pettyson and Prestwich. 

Common reasons for indemnity insurance

 Some of the most common indemnity policies cover: 

  • Planning permission/building regulations

Lack of planning permission for previous home extensions, loft, garage or basement conversions. There are also policies to cover missing building regulations certificates, including installation of double glazing to show it meets national standards. 

  • Restrictive covenant 

Protects against claims if a previous homeowner breached conditions in a property’s deeds, for example by building a new house or home extension without a required landowner’s consent. 

  • Chancel repairs 

A historic and rare liability requiring property owners in some areas to contribute to repairs to their local Anglican parish church. The liability dates to medieval times and is attached to the land -  former church land – which can be a long way from the church.

  • Insolvency Act

Relevant when a property (or a deposit for one) is gifted and the giver becomes insolvent within seven years of the gift. The policy protects against claims if a gifted property is later challenged by creditors.

  • Absence of easement 

Covers access disputes if a property relies on crossing someone’s land, for example shared driveways or drains in a neighbour’s garden. If the “right of easement” (permission to travel across the land) is unclear or undocumented, indemnity insurance protects in the event of a challenge to the use of the right of way.

How much does indemnity insurance cost?

Premiums are not hugely expensive and are calculated on the value of the property, not the level of risk. For example, a one-off policy for a missing boiler certificate might cost £80. But an indemnity to cover a home extension that doesn’t have the required planning approvals could cost several hundred pounds. 

Specialist insurances firms offer these policies. They’re typically arranged within 24 to 48 hours. In some cases, a quote may be offered in a matter of minutes but if you need a bespoke policy, it can take several days to arrange.

Who pays?

There is no fixed rule. While buyers benefit from the cover, sellers often pay to avoid holding up the sale. Sometimes buyers and sellers split the cost of the premiums.

Policies are tied to the property, so they can be passed to future owners.  They can last for decades but each policy is different, so always check the wording. “If an indemnity policy is put in place and in four or five years you sell, the buyer can still use it. However, if the property has gone up in price, you will have to top up the premium to increase the cover,” says Preen.

Who do I speak to about indemnity insurance? 

Speak only to your conveyancing solicitor. Each policy has strict terms and conditions. Even telling third parties about a potential problem could breach the terms. For instance, if you suspect the house you are interested in lacks the necessary planning permissions or building regulations approval, don’t tell the council before taking out a policy – doing so can invalidate it. “This is because you would have alerted the council there may be a problem,” explains Preen. 

Is it worth buying? 

Not always - but if your solicitor flags up an issue that could cost you thousands of pounds in future, it may be worth considering. 

If your conveyancing solicitor recommends indemnity insurance don’t just blindly accept it. Ask what risk is being covered? Is the policy necessary or has the risk period expired? What are the terms and conditions? Would a survey or safety check or retrospective permission provide more real peace of mind?  As Levi Solicitors note: “In recent years, these policies have become more common – although few are ever claimed on.”

If you are thinking of buying or selling your home, you may find some of these services useful: